- The news out of Ohio is not surprising given who's in office. Yawn. Moving on. There's nothing to see here. Get back to me in 2019.
- This Vancouver Sun article reminds me of people here in the States who want Amtrak to focus on only the Northeast Corridor. Both thoughts are preposterous. Furthermore, the writer has ties to the Rocky Mountaineer. Long distance travel should not be limited to the ultra wealthy.
- The state of Oklahoma is about to make a grand mistake and thwart any private effort to launch intercity rail service.
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Random thoughts #10
Tuesday, March 12, 2013
Peach State Ramblings: Abandoned S-Line
Parts of the S-Line between Savannah and Jacksonville have been abandoned. Shortline railroads use the area between Kingsland and Yulee, FL, and as a result, extra tracks would have to be built to accompany future passenger service (a commuter rail route is planned from Jacksonville's Union Terminal to Yulee). If the right of way is still available to be restored, the line could be used for SEHSR service between Raleigh and Jacksonville and Midwest-Florida service by an independent operator, bypassing potential conflicts with CSX and Amtrak. Now, on the other hand, if eminent domain is a major issue, then, a new route should be placed in the median of I-95 or parallel to the interstate.
Sunday, March 3, 2013
Tackling the Headlines 48
Possible Ethan Allen rerouting a likely detriment to eastern New York
Take: This would be an egregious example of killing the goose that laid the golden eggs. Saratoga & North Creek's service would take a big hit as it would only connect to the Adirondack. Assuming that Vermont opts for an Ethan Allen reroute over a brand new train route to Rutland, the state of New York has to step up to extend one or two Empire Service roundtrips to Saratoga Springs to maintain and maximize ridership. My solution is for Amtrak to extend Trains #236 or #238 and #235 (the train that currently runs on #290's schedule would become an Albany-NYP only train while the extended trains in question become daily if they are not already so and #239 would add Friday service).
All Aboard Florida announces new station location
Florida East Coast's passenger entity cleared a major hurdle in South Florida as it got the go ahead to build a new station on Evernia Street.
Take: Now, they need to resolve the Cocoa-Orlando Airport conflict with the Mormon Church.
More delays with the Amtrak-FEC route
Speaking of the FEC, this story is pretty self-explanatory.
Lawsuit against CAHSR tossed out
This stretched back to about five years ago where the issues were centered over whether the HSR route should even be along the Caltrain route north of San Jose as well as the routing between the Central and Silicon Valleys.
Take: Hopefully, all of the other lawsuits will meet the same fate.
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Random thoughts #9
- While it might serve as a contrarian viewpoint, I just couldn't agree with the writer that a Romney Administration plus a Republican Capitol Hill would have resulted in a logical transit solution. Three words: the Tea Party. That's right, had Mr. Lewyn's scenario played out, these anti-transit, anti-rail nutjobs would have run the show in D.C., not the more levelheaded folks.
- A public-private alternative to the current Washington-Hampton Roads service: Is it a joke or just practical? If Mr. Metcalf ever pulls it off, it'd be one of the biggest coups in the passenger rail industry. It would also provide Amtrak some competition in its own backyard--after all, the D.C.-Richmond-Hampton Roads is currently a southern extension of the Northeast Corridor. The likely route would result in Metcalf and Company contacting the route to a Virgin, a First Group, or even one of the European or Asian Express operators.
- In the event that a state or pact of states decides to replace Amtrak as the operator of corridor service, Congress should extend PRIIA Section 209. The first reason is the equipment issue. For states that use Amtrak equipment, an extension would be better than playing tag with Amtrak. For example, if Veolia wins the contract for the Blue Water and the Pere Marquette routes, Amtrak would continue to operate the routes until Veolia and the state of Michigan worked out a deal to get brand new rolling stock. Second, the terms of passenger rail bidding and competition should be made clearer by extension/new legislation. Bidding should be handled by a new task force or the FRA with fair terms for every operator.
Tackling the Headlines 47
President of Mexico outlines plan to rejuvenate passenger rail service
The new president wants to produce two new rail routes.
Take: When it comes to Mexico, moribund only begins to describe its passenger rail system. The only two links are hundreds of miles apart and don't connect. This is only a baby step.
National Express wins German operating contract
Take: This franchising plan may be a preview of the future of corridor service here in America once PRIIA's effects kick in.
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Tackling the Headlines 46
For now, very limited Amtrak-Maine Eastern connections
As it was reported in the February issue of Trains Magazine, connection and funding issues have put a dent in the Downeaster's extension to Brunswick. The preliminary plan by MERR is to cut the number of roundtrips in half from two to one, keep the train overnight in Brunswick, and to connect the afternoon westbound train from Rockland with Downeaster #688/698. MERR's director of operations Gordon Page told Bob Johnston "We have to be careful not to cannibalize our excursion product." The 30-minute rule has been cited as a likely reason for the potential lack of connections between the two railroads.When it comes to funding, the Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority applied for federal grants to leverage state bond money for a shop and for an enclosed three track layover building in a little used railyard near Brunswick, but was unsuccessful on both counts. As a result, the authority is still in search of a funding source.
Take: Oy vey!
Massachusetts is serious about additional trains
Governor Deval Patrick wants to beef up the Bay State's passenger service (go to page 19). He wants the following funded:- Restoration of the Inland Route (Amtrak)
- Commuter service on the South Coast Route (MBTA)
- Restoration of Cape Cod Service (Iowa Pacific's Cape Rail Line)
- Pittsfield-Berkshires route upgrades (Housatonic)
Take: At least Patrick's a proactive governor. There's a lot to like about the plan because the governor is getting other railroads involved. However, New England Central Railway's Central Corridor Route was omitted. This route will serve Palmer (where it will connect with the Inland services), Millers Falls and Amherst (which will lose Amtrak service next year).
Take: This is essentially building the Trans Dominion Express in increments.
Lynchburg yesterday, Norfolk today, Roanoke tomorrow
Outgoing Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell wants to extend the Lynchburg route west to Roanoke.Take: This is essentially building the Trans Dominion Express in increments.
Saturday, January 12, 2013
Rail Community, This Is A Crucial Year
The headline is spot on because 2013 potentially marks a turning point for passenger rail.
First, as several provisions of PRIIA run out, Congress may have to either roll them over as part of extensions, or they'll have to pass a brand new rail bill and given how difficult it was to pass a transportation bill for three years, it would be up to the rail community to press Congress to pass something by the end of this year.
Second, there is Section 209 in 2008's rail reform bill which will see states picking up 100% of the tab for routes that are less than 750 miles long.
Third, the fact that neither house of Congress flipped last year provides an opportunity for a more sensible passenger rail policy. The main reason is that the strength of the rail antagonistic Tea Party has been diminished.
Passenger rail policy is the same way because there are two diametrically opposing viewpoints that have muddied up reform: Rail advocates who want Congress to give unlimited money to Amtrak vs think tanks who believe in full-on privatization or that shutting down Amtrak without a reasonable alternative is rational. Anyone who's read my past entries already knows that both extremist alternatives are way off target. If you are reading my blog for the first time, I dismiss the first viewpoint because passenger rail has grown in the last three decades to the point that it is no longer plausible to give billions to a passenger operator that has already said that its future is in the Northeast while telling other regions that they are on their own. I shoot down the second viewpoint because Americans' love affair with car is over and the airlines are doing everything they can to make airline travel as unpleasant as possible. As a result, I advocate a mix of public and private ideas and revitalizing the intercity network before going full-on with HSR.
The Dream Scenario will result in members of both parties being open to competition after listening to other companies propose their ideas for making passenger rail better in the U.S. Ideally, current legislation would allow competitors to bid on Amtrak routes outside of the Northeast, but if the rules are proven obsolete, then, a new law would rectify that problem.
You say, "but what about the Class I railroads, they won't allow other companies on their rails?" Congress will have to address that issue by allaying their fears. If worst comes to worst, then, passenger routes outside of areas where Amtrak owns the tracks would be operated by a mix of the Big Seven and independent operators.
Rail advocacy groups can help out the cause by pushing forth this well-thought out vision for intercity rail nationally.
The Nightmare Scenario would happen if enough non-NEC Democrats take the True Believer bait and team up with Tea Partiers and other anti-rail Republicans to effectively block independent operators from establishing a foothold in America. The end result would be the preservation of the monopoly in passenger rail. Such a move would then lead to future Amtrak management pulling the company back into a state of complacency after being forced to get better in the wake of PRIIA.
Another thing is that the various independent and private operators who have popped up in the last four years are not going away, so in the wake of the AIPRO being formed and various Class II and Class III railroads planning their own services, the advocacy groups will show their true colors: Will they adapt to a post-monopoly era or will they go all in with Amtrak? When I use the phrase “going all in,” I mean that some of the groups having strong allegiances to Amtrak may launch disinformation campaigns not unlike the ones that opportunistic lawyers used against SNCF/Keolis in the name of the Holocaust.
The groups that can adapt will be rewarded by history for reviving American passenger rail travel. On the other hand, the groups that side with the True Believers are the ones who will be left out in the cold.
If rail advocates are caught choosing favorites (i.e., preserving the near monopoly), the AIPRO and other independent operators could tell them and their groups to take a hike while setting up their own organizations to promote rail travel—which would include the pro-competition advocacy groups.
First, as several provisions of PRIIA run out, Congress may have to either roll them over as part of extensions, or they'll have to pass a brand new rail bill and given how difficult it was to pass a transportation bill for three years, it would be up to the rail community to press Congress to pass something by the end of this year.
Second, there is Section 209 in 2008's rail reform bill which will see states picking up 100% of the tab for routes that are less than 750 miles long.
Third, the fact that neither house of Congress flipped last year provides an opportunity for a more sensible passenger rail policy. The main reason is that the strength of the rail antagonistic Tea Party has been diminished.
Grand Bargaining Is the Key
As we have seen with the fiscal cliff and debt ceiling debates in the last 18 months, nothing will get done in D.C. as long as both chambers of Congress are in the hands of different parties without some serious compromising.Passenger rail policy is the same way because there are two diametrically opposing viewpoints that have muddied up reform: Rail advocates who want Congress to give unlimited money to Amtrak vs think tanks who believe in full-on privatization or that shutting down Amtrak without a reasonable alternative is rational. Anyone who's read my past entries already knows that both extremist alternatives are way off target. If you are reading my blog for the first time, I dismiss the first viewpoint because passenger rail has grown in the last three decades to the point that it is no longer plausible to give billions to a passenger operator that has already said that its future is in the Northeast while telling other regions that they are on their own. I shoot down the second viewpoint because Americans' love affair with car is over and the airlines are doing everything they can to make airline travel as unpleasant as possible. As a result, I advocate a mix of public and private ideas and revitalizing the intercity network before going full-on with HSR.
What Type of Bargaining Will We Have?
What happens with passenger rail's future will depend on Congress's actions and railfans' approach.The Dream Scenario will result in members of both parties being open to competition after listening to other companies propose their ideas for making passenger rail better in the U.S. Ideally, current legislation would allow competitors to bid on Amtrak routes outside of the Northeast, but if the rules are proven obsolete, then, a new law would rectify that problem.
You say, "but what about the Class I railroads, they won't allow other companies on their rails?" Congress will have to address that issue by allaying their fears. If worst comes to worst, then, passenger routes outside of areas where Amtrak owns the tracks would be operated by a mix of the Big Seven and independent operators.
Rail advocacy groups can help out the cause by pushing forth this well-thought out vision for intercity rail nationally.
The Nightmare Scenario would happen if enough non-NEC Democrats take the True Believer bait and team up with Tea Partiers and other anti-rail Republicans to effectively block independent operators from establishing a foothold in America. The end result would be the preservation of the monopoly in passenger rail. Such a move would then lead to future Amtrak management pulling the company back into a state of complacency after being forced to get better in the wake of PRIIA.
A Primer For Advocates
The bottom line is that unless the Democrats regain the House next year and hold onto the White House in 2016, there will be no high speed rail funding in the foreseeable future. Increased passenger rail frequencies, expansion, and incremental speed upgrades should be rail advocates' main focus in the meanwhile.Another thing is that the various independent and private operators who have popped up in the last four years are not going away, so in the wake of the AIPRO being formed and various Class II and Class III railroads planning their own services, the advocacy groups will show their true colors: Will they adapt to a post-monopoly era or will they go all in with Amtrak? When I use the phrase “going all in,” I mean that some of the groups having strong allegiances to Amtrak may launch disinformation campaigns not unlike the ones that opportunistic lawyers used against SNCF/Keolis in the name of the Holocaust.
The groups that can adapt will be rewarded by history for reviving American passenger rail travel. On the other hand, the groups that side with the True Believers are the ones who will be left out in the cold.
If rail advocates are caught choosing favorites (i.e., preserving the near monopoly), the AIPRO and other independent operators could tell them and their groups to take a hike while setting up their own organizations to promote rail travel—which would include the pro-competition advocacy groups.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)