My Bio and This Blog's Purpose

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The New Passenger Paradigm Revisited

 

A decade ago, AIPRO's Ray Chambers laid out a potential shift in passenger rail that he called the New Passenger Paradigm. It's time to revisit the column that he wrote in Railway Age to see how far that idea has progressed.

Third paragraph: The AIPRO--now NAPRO--scored a major victory when Herzog landed the Hartford Line, which helped it to have the distinction of having intercity characteristics (more on that later). Even though it largely remains speculation, the San Joaquin JPA has been eyeing breaking away from Amtrak over unfavorable PRIIA terms over the past seven years. On the commuter front, NAPRO continues to largely come out victorious.

Fourth paragraph: The effort to move to a new model has largely stalled because of the extremely slow pace to implement new routes. Needless to say, this is something that has to be sped up drastically because for instance, the idea of implementing the FRA's Long Distance Study by 2040 is absolutely unacceptable. In the here and now, Chambers' original point is proven by Brightline's existence and the ideas by Dreamstar and Lunatrain to reinvent overnight travel.

Fifth paragraph: Corridor ID was a start, but that's in danger if the horrible elements of the proposed rail authorization carries over to the next Congress.

Sixth paragraph: In light of Congress mandating competition for intercity rail and Brightline getting most of the buzz for being the biggest non-Amtrak operator, a barriers remain. First, enforcement by Congress has been very light to nonexistent. Second, Brightline mostly appeals to a higher priced clientele, which is why it's ticket prices are more than Amtrak's. Third, most states remain reluctant to follow Connecticut's lead to consider anyone other than Amtrak for conventional/traditional intercity rail service. Credit to the Colorado DOT for opening up CoCo operations starting with Phase 2 in the 2030s.

As for the long-distance trains, the Pilot Program was never implemented and the FRA LDSS locked in Amtrak as the operator of the 15 proposed routes. Therefore, some kind of restructuring should be in the future--namely, long-distance interests being represented by people who have a national vision rather than a bunch of Northeastern bureaucrats.

Second column: Section 301 crawled so Corridor ID could run. I wouldn't be opposed to the idea of repealing Section 209--if it meant federal funding and producing interstate compacts, which would be a much better idea anyway.

Regarding non-NEC business opportunities, I don't know if any Class I railroads would go the Brightline path with real estate, but it could help the shortlines.