My Bio and This Blog's Purpose

Wednesday, February 22, 2023

MSG-Penn Station Redux

Penn Station redevelopment has reappeared over the past several months to a year. What it boils down to is that Madison Square Garden's lease expires at the end of July. 

There are three proposals that would separate MSG from the station while New York Governor Kathy Hochul is backing a fourth proposal that would keep the Garden on top of Penn Station in perpetuity. The big sticking point is once again James Dolan as he was a decade ago. 

Like I said in 2013, Dolan and MSG need to leave Penn Station even as NYC Mayor Eric Adams also supports keeping The Garden put. The truth is that the Moynihan Train Hall has actually made things less convenient for Amtrak passengers because they have a longer way to go if they want to catch the subway.

The end result will be reflective of train service in the nation's top region. If Hochul/Dolan/Adams prevail, then on one hand, it will be a sign that even the most important city in the U.S. will be forced to make due with at best a mediocre train station. On the other hand, it may prove what Corridor Capital's Bruce Richardson said a couple years ago: 

Passenger train stations will once again become centers of both transportation and commerce. The temples and palaces of the past will not be rebuilt, but a more sensible combination of stations and services as found today on Brightline in South Florida will become the standard template.

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

2022 Midterms and Rail

Given that transit agencies are still in various phases of recovery from the pandemic, there's very little to offer in the way of the future direction of commuter/regional rail outside of Florida.

Here's a link to all of the transit-related referenda that were on the ballot last month. Based on the results, we don't have to worry about this particular nightmare scenario any time soon. However, it could still be in play over the next few years as the Senate and presidency could flip in '24.

Sunday, July 17, 2022

Random thoughts #15

  1. This is what happens when you have the largest city in the nation without passenger train service for the last 26 years and a state DOT that has been passive at best towards intercity rail. Leaders in Arizona are letting a golden opportunity slip by their fingers.
  2. Connects US is proof that Amtrak President Stephen Gardner is the anti-matrix theory guy.

  3. As I said almost a decade ago, Amtrak doesn’t have a funding problem, it has a management problem, and nothing emphasizes this more than the various equipment and mechanical issues that passengers have experience over the past year and a half.

  4. Also, the way management handled the long-distance trains throughout this entire pandemic is way beyond appalling.

  5. The gist of Disney's about face last month is that the organization is acting like a petulant child because how dare Brightline serve Mickey Mouse's competitors when the Disney organization only wanted the operator to cater to them

Tuesday, August 17, 2021

The King of Passenger Trains

Background: This three-part series (1 2 3) is a good place to look 

Part 1: Starting things up

After a half century, the time has come to hit the reset button and start over because the Amtrak experiment has only resulted in mediocrity with passenger rail.  I would split the intercity into two categories--regional and overnight. The former would be run by the companies that also handle commuter routes while letting new companies run the overnight services.

I would rely on experienced people in the travel industry and implement the best aspects. My main focus would be on long distance trains and leave the shorter runs to multistate pacts. Since the overnight trains are in need of an overhaul, I would revert back to sleeping cars' roots as hotels on wheels as a way of luring travelers.

Speaking of night trains, luring executives from Europe or Asia would be a good idea since they're miles ahead of us at this point.

Part 2: The Matrix

The matrix theory connects passengers to previously unimaginable destinations. For my hypothetical rail company, I will use the Crescent's original route via Montgomery and Mobile as my sample service.  Atlanta would be a matrix point as it would be a transfer point for regional routes to Savannah, Chattanooga and Nashville. The current Crescent route would also be used as the Gulf Coast Corridor for daytime travel between Atlanta and New Orleans, a New York-Fort Worth overnight route and a transcontinental Atlanta-Dallas-Los Angeles service.

Part 3: Operations

The trains would be daily and would run every six to eight hours. My Crescent Group would have the namesake train as a premium train alongside a second frequency, and I would also own the Fort Worth service and L.A. transcon as a way of diversifying.

Instead of the depersonalization that has been a main part of the Amtrak Era, stations would be staffed with people who actually know a thing or two about train travel. When it comes to the future of train stations, the Brightline model--which resembles the airline model--is the best way to go.

The statement about host railroads' stance on infrequent trains goes against everything I've seen on message boards.

Monday, August 16, 2021

The New Passenger Paradigm Five Years Later

I remember reading up on a Railway Age article five years ago on something called the New Passenger Paradigm. In the article, AIPRO's Ray Chambers laid out how things were shifting in the world of passenger rail. 

Given where things are now, I say that the pace to a post-monopoly environment has been glacially slow. Consider the evidence:

  • Congress has consistently failed to back up its action (i.e. it has talked about the need for more competition among corridors and overnight trains but did nothing to make sure the proper provisions in PRIIA and the FAST Act were followed)
  • Once the Tea Party backlash happened, the Obama Administration largely lost interest in even building a decent passenger rail system
  • The Trump Administration aside from its open hostility towards CAHSR, was all talk and no action on even regular passenger rail, belying its campaign gripes about China having faster trains than America
  • The AIPRO itself dissolved last year to no fanfare after it received virtually no support from the rail community and scant media coverage while some of its members formed a separate mass transit trade group
  • The U.S. still hasn't had more than one private passenger rail organization at a time since 1983 (the Rio Grande and Georgia Railroad's mixed trains)--or the end of 1978 (Rio Grande, Rock Island, Southern, Reading) if you're talking about true passenger trains. While Brightline started up in early 2018, the Saratoga & North Creek became a fallen flag shortly thereafter
  • When it comes to bidding, Herzog's operation of CT Rail is the closest that any Amtrak commuter competitor has come to running intercity rail
  • Other than Pennsylvania and the San Joaquin Valley, no state entity is even willing to challenge Amtrak (see the 2018 fiasco with the loss of discounts where only California's three JPAs pushed back against the Anderson regime and kept said discounts)
Even after reading this article and understanding some behind the scenes actions, it still isn't much comfort when it seems like getting there from here is a near impossibility when rail activists are much more comfortable defending the status quo and ridiculing any non-Amtrak passenger operator. Calling the national network skeletal at this point is being way too kind when expansion should have been on the agenda decades ago--oh wait, Graham Claytor did that only for that to be undone by his NEC successors and Congress implemented prohibitions after the collapse of the Mail and Express plan in 2001.